Thats everything from Bulbasaur to Mewtwo
As such, the only card from the year that actually feels broken to me is Lin Sivvi, which might not look like much today but was more or less a game-breaking card back in 2000
As has been established when discussing Bolass Citadel, paying for cards with life is an incredibly powerful effect
PSA Gem Mint 10 Premium A signed Dark Charizard graded PSA Near Mint 7 sold for $13,200 in August 2020
14%inclusion 13%synergy 248 decks 1.72K decks Bulk Up 14%inclusion 11%synergy 1.63K decks 11.5K decks Collective Resistance 14%inclusion 3%synergy 1.63K decks 11.9K decks Silkguard 13%inclusion 8%synergy 1.50K decks 11.9K decks Inspiring Call 13%inclusion 1%synergy 1.49K decks 11.9K decks Psychotic Fury 12%inclusion 10%synergy 1.39K decks 11.9K decks Blossoming Defense 11%inclusion 7%synergy 1.28K decks 11.9K decks Nature's Claim 10%inclusion -3%synergy 1.13K decks 11.9K decks Signature Slam 9.1%inclusion 7%synergy 1.08K decks 11.9K decks Cosmic Hunger 8.7%inclusion 8%synergy 1.03K decks 11.9K decks Invigorate 8.6%inclusion 6%synergy 1.02K decks 11.9K decks Rabid Gnaw 8.5%inclusion 8%synergy 1.01K decks 11.9K decks Monstrous Rage 8.3%inclusion 7%synergy 989 decks 11.9K decks Windswift Slice 8.1%inclusion 7%synergy 965 decks 11.9K decks Vines of Vastwood 8.1%inclusion 6%synergy 956 decks 11.9K decks Trash the Town 7.0%inclusion 6%synergy 830 decks 11.9K decks Giant Growth 6.8%inclusion 5%synergy 809 decks 11.9K decks Invigorating Surge 6.7%inclusion 5%synergy 793 decks 11.9K decks Bolt Bend 6.6%inclusion -2%synergy 781 decks 11.9K decks Royal Treatment 6.5%inclusion 4%synergy 774 decks 11.9K decks Force of Vigor 6.5%inclusion 1%synergy 768 decks 11.9K decks Tifa's Limit Break 6.2%inclusion 5%synergy 391 decks 6.31K decks Giantfall 6.2%inclusion 6%synergy 214 decks 3.46K decks Thrill of Possibility 6.2%inclusion 0%synergy 730 decks 11.9K decks Sorceries Stump Stomp 52%inclusion 35%synergy 6.22K decks 11.9K decks Blasphemous Act 50%inclusion 7%synergy 5.97K decks 11.9K decks Bushwhack 48%inclusion 43%synergy 5.74K decks 11.9K decks Cultivate 46%inclusion -3%synergy 5.46K decks 11.9K decks Nature's Lore 46%inclusion 9%synergy 5.46K decks 11.9K decks Rampant Growth 39%inclusion -4%synergy 4.61K decks 11.9K decks Bridgeworks Battle 38%inclusion 28%synergy 4.56K decks 11.9K decks Three Visits 33%inclusion 5%synergy 3.87K decks 11.9K decks Contest of Claws 29%inclusion 27%synergy 3.38K decks 11.9K decks Farseek 27%inclusion -5%synergy 3.20K decks 11.9K decks Waltz of Rage 25%inclusion 24%synergy 3.02K decks 11.9K decks Kodama's Reach 25%inclusion -8%synergy 3K decks 11.9K decks Rishkar's Expertise 24%inclusion 2%synergy 2.84K decks 11.9K decks Primal Might 21%inclusion 18%synergy 2.46K decks 11.9K decks Beastie Beatdown 18%inclusion 17%synergy 2.10K decks 11.9K decks Vandalblast 15%inclusion -3%synergy 1.81K decks 11.9K decks Rhino's Rampage 15%inclusion 13%synergy 760 decks 5.03K decks Decimate 14%inclusion -8%synergy 1.70K decks 11.9K decks Nibelheim Aflame 13%inclusion 12%synergy 861 decks 6.49K decks Season of Gathering 12%inclusion 7%synergy 1.38K decks 11.9K decks Harmonize 11%inclusion -5%synergy 1.36K decks 11.9K decks Animist's Might 10%inclusion 9%synergy 1.21K decks 11.9K decks Hull Breach 10%inclusion 1%synergy 1.18K decks 11.9K decks Felling Blow 10%inclusion 9%synergy 1.09K decks 11.4K decks Bala Ged Recovery 9.3%inclusion -1%synergy 1.10K decks 11.9K decks Super Combo 9.1%inclusion 8%synergy 273 decks 3.01K decks Prey Upon 8.6%inclusion 7%synergy 1.02K decks 11.9K decks Fangs of Kalonia 8.1%inclusion 6%synergy 960 decks 11.9K decks Smell Fear 8.1%inclusion 7%synergy 959 decks 11.9K decks Domri's Ambush 7.5%inclusion 6%synergy 894 decks 11.9K decks Go Nuts
Back in March of 2024, WotC banned sticker and attraction cards from multiple formats, so although some are still allowed in Commander, in this list, Ill focus mainly on black-bordered cards from sets like Adventures in the Forgotten Realms, AFR Commander, and Unfinity
